This post and photos may contain Amazon or other affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase something through any link, I may receive a small commission at no extra charge to you. All opinions are my own.
I cannot tell you how excited I was when I finally succeeded at making homemade Paleo mayonnaise! It’s not an easy feat, I tell you because I have tried many methods and recipes until I got just the right combination of technique and ingredients.
Nothing makes you want to lose your religion quite like ending up with aioli instead of creamy mayo after many failed attempts. Seriously, I was pulling my hair out each time I got this amazing whipped mayo only to have it turn back to liquid on the next drizzle of oil. Grrrrr!!! So when I finally got this nailed down, I wanted to do a happy dance! Yay!
Tips For Making Paleo Mayonnaise
Your egg needs to be room temperature. Also, you must barely drizzle the oil into the food processor. It is key to ending up with the right whipped texture. I have tried the hand whisk method…sore wrists. I have tried a stick blender…too frothy. The food processor ended up being the way to go for me. The results were far better than the other two methods.
Also, I can’t emphasize enough how important it is to use the extra light olive oil to make this Paleo mayonnaise. Buy the cheap stuff. DO NOT use your good EVOO for this recipe! It will be too strong tasting and extra virgin oil is too thick for making good mayonnaise. Trust me on this one. Now go have fun making your new mayonnaise recipe without all the added ingredients in the store-bought stuff. Hopefully, I can help you master it on your first try!
You now have delicious, homemade and healthier mayo for all your favorite recipes. It’s much cheaper this way, too! Store in the refrigerator in a mason jar or other sealed container for up to a week or so.
- 1 large egg room temperature (very important!!)
- 2 tbsp fresh squeezed lemon juice
- 1/2 tsp mustard powder
- 1/4 tsp white pepper
- 1 tsp sea salt
- 1 cup extra light olive oil not EVOO
- Combine egg, lemon juice, mustard powder, white pepper and salt in the food processor and blend until frothy
- Using the drip hole in the top of the processor, drizzle the oil in a few drops at a time (do not rush this emulsion process...it will result in a liquid mess)
- Once you have a good bit of drops mixed in, very slowly (I cannot over emphasize VERY SLOWLY) drizzle the oil down the tube little by little until all is mixed in and mixture is nice and creamy