8ozfreshly shredded extra-sharp cheddar cheeseuse the block cheese and shred it, not the already shredded cheese, it makes a difference in the texture
8ozfreshly shredded sharp cheddar cheese
8ozcream cheesesoftened
1/2cupmayonnaiseI use an olive oil blend but Duke's is a traditional southern staple
1/4tspgarlic powder
1/4tspground cayenne pepper
1/4tsponion powder
1/4cupdiced jalapenosthoroughly drained (in the jar- these have a great flavor and softer texture than fresh)
14 oz jar diced pimento, drained well
sea salt and pepper to taste
Instructions
Place all ingredients, except salt and pepper, in the bowl of an electric mixer and blend at medium speed until well combined.
Season with salt and pepper and serve.
Store leftover spread in a sealed container in the refrigerator.
Notes
I cannot encourage you enough to shred your own cheese. The flavor and texture are so much better with freshly shredded cheddar.
Be sure to drain the jalapeños and pimentos well. If there's any excess liquid, it may make your pimento cheese watery and unpleasant.
Not a huge fan of spicy food? That's okay. Omit the jalapeños and cayenne to tone down the heat a bit. Add fresh chopped herbs instead like parsley and chives.